Successful Appeal Case Study: Capital Gains Exemption Allowed Under India–Singapore DTAA

Client Background

A Mumbai-based individual, who was a tax resident of Singapore, had invested in Indian equity and debt mutual funds over the years. During the relevant financial year, she redeemed and sold these investments, resulting in substantial short-term capital gains.

While filing her Indian Income Tax Return, she claimed exemption on these capital gains under Article 13 of the India–Singapore Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), contending that the gains were taxable only in Singapore.

However, the Income Tax Department denied the DTAA benefit and sought to tax the entire capital gains in India.

Tax Notice and Appeal

The taxpayer had declared:

• Short-term capital gains on debt mutual funds: ₹88 lakh

• Short-term capital gains on equity mutual funds: ₹46 lakh

She claimed treaty protection under the India–Singapore DTAA.

Department’s Stand

The Assessing Officer rejected the exemption claim, arguing that:

• Mutual fund units derive substantial value from assets located in India

• Therefore, India retained taxation rights over such gains

The matter was escalated to the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), which upheld the Assessing Officer’s view.

Appeal Before ITAT Mumbai

We then filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Mumbai Bench.

Key Argument

We relied on a number of judicial precedents, including a comparable ruling under the India–UAE DTAA, where the ITAT Cochin had granted similar capital gains relief.

The central question before the Tribunal was:

Can India tax capital gains earned by a Singapore tax resident from redemption of Indian mutual fund units, or are such gains taxable only in Singapore under Article 13(5)?

ITAT Mumbai Ruling in Favour of our Client

The ITAT Mumbai examined Article 13 of the India–Singapore DTAA in detail and held that:

• Article 13(4) applies only to gains from transfer of shares in a company

• Mutual fund units are not shares, as mutual funds in India are constituted as trusts, not companies

Therefore, capital gains from mutual fund units fall under the residuary clause — Article 13(5).

Tribunal’s Key Observations

• Mutual fund units and shares are distinct instruments under Indian law

• Units cannot be equated with “shares” for treaty purposes

• Since Article 13(5) allocates taxing rights to the country of residence, India cannot tax such gains

Outcome: Successful Tax Relief

The Tribunal allowed our Client's appeal and ruled that:

✅ Short-term capital gains from Indian mutual fund units earned by a Singapore tax resident are not taxable in India
✅ Exclusive taxing rights lie with Singapore under Article 13(5)
✅ Treaty benefits override domestic tax provisions under Section 90(2) of the Income-tax Act

This decision reaffirmed that DTAA protections apply strongly in cross-border investment structures when interpreted correctly.

Why This Case Matters for NRIs & Foreign Residents

This ruling is a landmark for:

• Singapore-based NRIs investing in Indian mutual funds

• Foreign tax residents claiming DTAA relief on capital gains

• Investors facing scrutiny on treaty-based exemptions

• Cross-border tax planning and compliance

Expert Representation & Strategic Litigation Support

This appeal highlights the importance of:

• Correct interpretation of DTAA provisions

• Reliance on judicial precedents

• Strong appellate advocacy before ITAT

With the right tax strategy, Our Clients are able to successfully defend treaty benefits against incorrect departmental interpretations.

Need Help With DTAA Capital Gains Exemption?

Our firm regularly assists NRIs and global residents with:

• Capital gains taxation on Indian investments

• DTAA advisory and litigation support

• Scrutiny assessments and ITAT appeals

• Cross-border compliance and tax structuring

Call to Action

Facing income-tax scrutiny or complex tax notices?
Connect with CA Mitesh and Associates for reliable, expert-driven tax consulting services—and resolve your tax challenges with confidence and ease.

CA Mitesh and Associates is India's leading CA Firm Firm with special focus on accurate Income Tax Return Filing and Handling Income Tax Notices in India.                                                                                                                                      Contact us via WhatsApp: Click Here  or Email: info@mnpartners.in

DISCLAIMER

CMS Meta: Income Tax Notices | Income Tax Appeals | NRI Taxation | DTAA | Computation of Capital Gains Tax NRI | TDS Matters for NRI | NRI ITR Filing | NRI Tax Refunds | NRI Stock Trading | NRI Investments | NRI Mutual Funds | NRI Investment Planning | NRI Repatriation | NRI Remittance | NRI USDT Arbitrage | Providing a CA Certificate (Form 15CB) | NRI Business Setup in India | NRI FDI Policy | NRI Entry Strategy and Structuring Advice | NRI RBI and FEMA Compliance | Lower Tax Deduction | Tax Exemption Certificate | Sale of Property by NRI | Property Due Diligence NRI | Property Agreement Drafting NRI | Power of Attorney (PoA) | Property Registration (only in Mumbai) NRI| Property Legal Counsel NRI | Repatriation of Funds | Double Taxation Treaty Benefits | Form 15 CA / CB